Lila was tired of her cold mother-in-law, Carol, ruining her husband Bill’s birthdays. This year, Lila planned to hide Carol’s gift to save Bill from disappointment. Bill’s nervousness about his mother’s gift was palpable as his birthday approached.

A couple of days before his birthday, a package from Carol arrived. Their neighbor, Tom, took it in, and Lila picked it up, finding a pair of socks inside. Determined to protect Bill, she decided to hide the gift.

On Bill’s birthday, Lila planned a perfect celebration with friends and thoughtful gifts, making Bill happier than ever. A few days later, Tom accidentally brought the package over, and Bill opened it, revealing the socks. His disappointment was evident.

Lila apologized, explaining she wanted to spare him the hurt. Unfortunately, Bill’s brother, Mike, overheard and called their mother, sparking family drama. Carol and Bill’s brothers accused Lila of being toxic and ruining relationships.

Despite the backlash, Bill appreciated Lila’s effort to shield him from his mother’s neglect. They decided to start new birthday traditions, focusing on joy and love rather than expecting anything from Carol.

As they walked one evening, Bill suggested, “How about a road trip for my next birthday? Just the two of us?”

Lila smiled, “I’d love that.” They looked forward to creating new, happy memories together.